I was eleven years old, and I was going to throw the perfect tea party. I had the porcelain set my grandma brought back from a trip. I had my cousin's stuffed rabbit wearing a bow tie. I had a pitcher of water with a slice of lemon floating in it. Not tea. Pretend tea. And my Auntie—also my SDA Sabbath School teacher—still found a way to ruin it.
It was raining that afternoon, which in hindsight was the sky's way of giving me a heads-up. She walked in, looked at the tiny cups, and asked me very gently, the way you ask a person whether they have thought this tattoo through: "Sobrina, what are we pretending to drink?"
"Tea," I said innocently.
"Princesa, did you know that when you pretend to drink tea you're training your heart to enjoy sin?"
I looked at my rabbit with the bow tie. He was crushed with disappointment. With a tear in my eye, I put the lid back on the teapot and apologized to the rabbit. No tea-party today.
Nobody in my childhood ever explained why a cup of leaves steeped in hot water, a drink half the planet shares at breakfast, was a spiritual hazard. It was simply known, like the capital of Peru, the second angel's message, and the fact that gluten has no business pretending to be meat.
Years later, at an SDA University, I did the one thing most SDAs never do. I went and read the source. I discovered that Ellen White did not say tea was unwise, or unhealthy, or a bit inappropriate for an eleven-year-old's party. She said something far more sinister.
Let's Start with the Word "Sin"
In 1896 she wrote:
Tea and coffee drinking is a sin, an injurious indulgence, which, like other evils, injures the soul.1
Not a bad habit. Not merely unhealthy. A sin, the word the Bible uses for murder and idolatry. And Earl Grey, apparently, got a seat at that table.
Now notice the phrase "injures the soul." Not the stomach. Not your sleep schedule. The soul. Somewhere in the invisible anatomy of every human being there is a delicate organ that gets bruised by a teabag. No doctor has found it. Neither has the Bible. Neither tea nor coffee appears anywhere in Scripture. Leviticus never found room to warn anyone about a cup of chamomile. The Almighty somehow let this sin go unmentioned until Ellen White came along in the nineteenth century to warn us of this horrific spiritual danger.
Lips Undefiled
On November 1, 1897, she doubled down:
The practice of using liquor, tobacco, tea, and coffee must be overcome by the converting power of God. There shall nothing enter into the kingdom of God that defileth.2
Look at the company in that sentence. Liquor. Tobacco. Tea. Coffee. One of these things is a leading cause of preventable death all over the world, and one of them is what my "sinful" non-SDA grandma serves with a cookie.
What's the remedy: "the converting power of God." Converting power! Obviously, no one who dares to drink tea has been converted. Tea-drinkers need "converting power!" The same power that knocked Saul off his horse on the road to Damascus is now being dispatched to help Adventists kick the tea habit to save their souls.
The last sentence is the showstopper: "There shall nothing enter into the kingdom of God that defileth." That echoes Revelation 21:27, where the surrounding lines are about the cowardly and the deceitful, not the tea-bibber.
Picture it: Saint Peter at the pearly gates, clipboard in hand. "Let's see. Lifetime of service. Fed the hungry. Read Ellen White's books. Went to SDA schools. Forgave everyone. Good, good, good...oh...oops, hold on. There's a note here. Tuesday afternoon, 2001. Gave fake tea to a stuffed rabbit after your tia left the room. Take that door to the left, the one labeled 'hell.' Next."
Diseases of Every Stripe and Type
Of course, she also sold the health angle. In an 1887 manuscript we read:
Diseases of every stripe and type have been brought upon human beings by the use of tea and coffee…3
"Every stripe and type." I love it. It sounds like a tailor describing his fabric samples. Notice that she doesn't name a single disease, which was smart on her part. You cannot be fact-checked on the unspecified.
People have since fact-checked it anyway. In 2020, a large study of over 100,000 people found that tea consumption was associated with reduced risks of cardiovascular disease and all-cause mortality, especially among those consistent habitual tea drinkers. I hate to rain on White's parade, but sometimes the truth is difficult to swallow.
Virtually every other study on tea in existence says something similar: tea is good for one's health.4 If you are pregnant, don't go crazy with caffeine. That is the one warning that modern science supports. But sadly for White, she never warned against excessive tea-drinking while pregnant. I'll be generous and say she didn't have to since she banned all women from drinking it.
But "diseases of every stripe and type"? No. That did not survive the science. The one stripe that definitely came from tea was the stripe of guilt on my eleven-year-old forehead. It took me years to get over the shame.
The Tea Party as Crime Scene
Now we reach my favorite passage, because Ellen White describes a tea party with the eye of a detective:
When these tea and coffee users meet together for social entertainment, the effects of their pernicious habit are manifest. All partake freely of the favorite beverages, and as the stimulating influence is felt, their tongues are loosened, and they begin the wicked work of talking against others. Their words are not few or well chosen. The tidbits of gossip are passed around, too often the poison of scandal as well.5
"Tidbits of gossip are passed around." Like a plate of sandwiches. I can see the scene. And I will say this: she clearly attended gatherings of women, and she took notes.
But here is what puzzles me. I grew up in a church where nobody drank tea, nobody drank coffee, nobody drank anything stronger than carob milk, and the gossip moved faster than the offering plate. We were as sober as judges and as informed about each other's lives as a government agency. I knew everyone who was seen munching on a ham sandwich at a quinceaƱera, heard watching the soccer game on their TV on Sabbath, or was suspected of fooling around before they got married. All that without coffee or tea.
Meanwhile, our Cuban neighbor drank cafecito three times a day and never said a cruel word about anyone, mostly because she was too busy handing out food in our neighborhood. If caffeine loosened her tongue, all it ever said was "have you enough to eat?"
An Unnatural Appetite for Leaves
In 1899 she tightened the screws:
The indulgence of unnatural appetite, whether for tea, coffee, tobacco, or liquor, is intemperance, and is at war with the laws of life and health. By using these forbidden articles a condition of things is created in the system which the Creator never designed. This indulgence in any of the members of the human family is sin.6
Unnatural? Tea is a leaf. Mate is a leaf. Coffee is a seed from a plant, grown in the dirt, in the sun, by the same Creator who, according to Genesis 1:29, gave humanity "every seed-bearing plant on the face of the earth" for food, and who, in verse 31, "saw all that he had made, and it was very good." Somewhere between Genesis and Battle Creek, a leaf stopped being natural. The plant did not change. The source of inspiration did.
And "a condition of things which the Creator never designed"? As if He were surprised by the caffeine. Somebody designed that leaf. Either the Creator made it and gave it to us, or else it was one of the "amalgamated species" that God did not create. Pick one.
Notice also the sleight of hand. She folds tea and coffee into one bucket with liquor and tobacco, and gives the bucket a single name, "intemperance." Once everything is in the same bucket, you never have to prove each item is equally harmful. You just repeat the list, and the list does the arguing.
In Argentina, mate is not just a drink. It is how friendships are made: one gourd, one straw, passed around the circle, everybody talking and laughing. The rule is that you do not refuse it. We were not allowed to take part. I spent my childhood looking at the most important social ritual in my country the way other children look into a candy-store window. In Argentina we have a word for holier-than-thou Adventists who refuse the mate: Sadventistas.
Sin Converted into a Fundraiser
Now we come to the passage that calls us to follow the money. In 1885 she asked:
Will our people see and feel the sin of indulging perverted appetite? Will they discard tea, coffee, flesh meats, and all stimulating food, and devote the means expended for these hurtful indulgences to spreading the truth?7
What's hilarious is that she was purchasing and eating "flesh meats" when she wrote this law!
The first sentence labels these things as sin. The second sentence hits the wallet. First the moral crisis, then the donation envelope. Sins do not usually come with a payment plan. I never heard an SDA say, "Will our people discard porn and devote the means expended on it to missions?" Maybe that's because almost every SDA university student I knew was either indulging in porn or paying for a Netflix subscription and watching naughty shows. At least, that's what I heard when the university girls got together to drink cocoa and gossip.
I am sure White was sincere about saving her people from draining their vital force. But a rule that ends with "and send the savings to the cause" has a way of making the church look like the beneficiary of your repentance. If tea is a sin that injures the soul, the answer is to stop. If tea is a line item that can be redirected, then maybe the offense is not the leaf. Maybe it's that the money went for something you truly enjoyed instead of into White's pocket.
And then there's that list again. Tea, coffee, flesh meats, and "all stimulating food." In Argentina, like most countries south of the border, we don't talk about White's laws against meat. That baloney simply doesn't fly in our culture. Pastors eat meat, everyone eats it. But my favorite is: "all stimulating food." In Latin culture, that covers pretty much anything other than a mango.
What the Bible Actually Says About Your Cup
Let me get serious for a minute, as a palate cleanser. Here is what Scripture says about eating, drinking, and what makes a person unclean.
Jesus, in Mark 7:15: "Nothing outside a person can defile them by going into them. Rather, it is what comes out of a person that defiles them."
Nothing. Period. By Jesus' standard, the problem at the tea party was never the tea. It was the talking.
Paul, in Romans 14:17: "For the kingdom of God is not a matter of eating and drinking, but of righteousness, peace and joy in the Holy Spirit." Not a matter of eating and drinking. So when we are told that nothing that "defileth" will enter the kingdom, and the defilement turns out to be a mug of coffee, we know the messenger is spewing nonsense.
Paul again, Colossians 2:16: "Therefore do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink." Anyone. Including a Sabbath School teacher standing over a teapot of pretend tea.
Finally, in 1 Timothy 5:23, an apostle writes to a young pastor: "Stop drinking only water, and use a little wine because of your stomach and your frequent illnesses." I know the standard SDA argument, that "wine" in the Bible meant grape juice. My point is simpler. If Paul can prescribe wine for a stomachache, I think the church can allow a peppermint tea for the nausea I get when I recall growing up Adventist.
My Verdict: Pour Yourself Something
If you choose not to drink tea for whatever reason, I respect that. After all, the kingdom is not about food and drink.
What I object to is the other thing: taking a quiet pleasure shared across almost every culture on earth and calling it a sin that injures the soul. Taking a leaf in hot water and telling a child that her pretend version trains the heart in rebellion. Taking a plate of gossip and blaming the beverage. And trading a sin for an offering envelope.
So here is my message to a church that has spent more than a century monitoring what goes into everyone's cup: the soul can survive a Mate. What it struggles to survive is being taught that a quiet afternoon with a hot tea in icy weather is a threat to eternity.
Ellen White rained on my tea party. I've since brought an umbrella. That umbrella is called the Word of God.
And yes, I had a cup of tea while writing this.